Okay so I decided to write down some ideas I had for creepypastas and other Internet/web horror worITTL and to see what you think of them.
First of all this is way too much. You should DM me next time. When I near 500 pages or so I'm going back to delete non bookmarked posts and this will be axed but that's still a long way away.
1999
The author doesn’t plagiarise Alantutorial and continues to update the story instead of running off after being called out.
That is not what happened at least from my research. The story was uploaded on a wiki and edited without him knowing. Other people added more to the story including the Alan tutorial plagiarism. The author seems to have a wanted to deliberately end the story on a vague note, letting the reader speculate if the protagonist was killed by Mr.Bear and so never updated or if he just decided not to post again. However the story did get a live action adaptation in 10 minute parts. ITTL that version has Mr.Bear attack the protagonist because that would make for a better climax in the new medium.
Abandoned by Disney
Same as OTL.
Same, though I personally always wondered why the costume was photo negative. This also applies to the rest of the Disney creepy pastas by the same author set in the same universe, though there may be updates depending on different events in Disney's history ITTL.
Anasi's Goatman Story
Same as OTL.
Same. though maybe a bit better written.
Annie96 is typing...
Same as OTL.
Same.
Annora Petrova
Same as OTL.
Same.
Same.
Borrasca
Same as OTL. Considered one of the best creepypastas of all time.
Same. Though I'm not sure if it should get a sequel as that may ruin the intended horror ending.
Cameraheads
Is an actual ARG that isn’t abandoned after a few posts, still becomes lost and rediscovered several years later, with most people agreeing that the story behind it is more interesting than the story itself.
Yeah no I'm saying its not lost and so isn't as popular as like with Firefly getting cancelled boosted its reputation and it otherwise would have just been seem as meh. The same applies here. though to clarify this doesn't apply to everything. The Owl House was still a successful show even before it got screwed by the network but that doesn't apply here.
Same, though with a better made "recreation" not with stock footage but with actual puppets.
Wasn't familiar with the series so it currently is the same.
Same.
Found on the Tape
Is eventually solved by 2016, instead of remaining an unsolved ARG.
You'll have to DM me information on this I couldn't find anything.
Could still exist since Minecraft still exists.
I'm a 911 operator. Just had the most terrifying call...
Same as OTL.
Same.
I'm a Search and Rescue Officer for the US Forest Service, I have some stories to tell
Same as OTL.
Same.
Jordan Underneath
He doesn’t purge his old channel, while also keeping on doing the same kind of content that he wants to do and is happy doing.
Starts a new separate channel while the old one is still available.
My Dad’s Tapes
The series doesn’t fumble at the end, and manages to have an official conclusion instead of ceasing uploads.
Without the Margarita scene and does have a conclusion.
My dead girlfriend keeps messaging me on Facebook.
Same as OTL unless Facebook doesn’t exist ITTL.
Facebook is Facemash ITTL. Its original name born out of Zuckerberg having to build HarvardConnection.com as he promised to the Winklevoss twins.
Ok.
Penpal
Same as OTL. Considered one of the best creepypastas of all time.
Ok.
Ok,
Psychosis
Same as OTL, and is still known for its amazing plot twist at the end. Considered one of the best creepypastas of all time.
Reallly?...that. I saw that coming a mile away and I only read the story just now. I will not award it those accolades. Le tit exist and be popular.
Slenderman
Still exists and becomes popular, but neither the stabbing or the bad movies ever happen, with the king of creepypastas still decreasing in popularity, but having a cleaner reputation. Marble Hornets also still exists as a result.
Once again. Slenderman does not exist due to the complex butterflies required in him still existing. Though I did joke in my ideas that the Recovered, a 2006 film by Red Letter Media's creators about a bald pale man in a business suit haunting a little girl was unexpectedly popular and so resulted in the character appearing earlier but with his origins more traceable to that film.
Sonic.exe
Is better written. Like you suggested maybe ITTL it’s just a single game rather than a story.
For those not in the DM, my pitch was Sonic.Exe is released but only as a game with creepy visuals and no accompanying story. Naturally the internet went wild, resulting in the Needlemouse series creating a compelling story of a girl who was murdered, her spirit possessing Sonic in the game and now brought in her murderers in the roles of the characters she murders. "In this world....I am God." and so on. Sonic EYX, largely seen as a better Sonic.Exe is essentially set after the spirit has become even more twisted and is still torturing the souls.
Squidward's Suicide/Red Mist
It’s better written, like what you provided in your suggestion in our DMs.
My suggestion is essentially that the Red Mist is something the town panics about and there are warnings of it. The Mist travels through the town and infects people. Squidward is infected after he gives a failed performance and commits suicide to avoid turning with Spongebob and Patrick mourning his death after the Mist passes. The Mist is revealed to be from an animal ripped apart and its blood spreading. Think something like a Great White Shark eating a man.
Suicide Mouse
Same as OTL?
Ok.
Ted the Caver
Same as OTL.
Ok. Though the real figure it was based on survived ITTL.
The Human Pet
“This Tape Will Send You To Hell” is never uploaded, with the series continuing on and eventually coming to an official end in 2010.
Sure.
Sure.
The Russian Sleep Experiment
May or may not exist depending on if the Soviet Union still exists in this reality.
Not so much ends as reforms under a new Government, though this story would still exist.
The Spongebob Guy
Same as OTL.
Would be different as Spongebob is different what with ending sooner and being called Spongeboy for one. possibly butterlying away the Spongebob Guy.
Tribe Twelve
Considering that I just learned about this today when searching up this series again, I’m not sure what should be done surrounding what the creator did, either he never does those things or the series simply never exists.
Likely doesn't exist because there is no Slenderman, though I do imagine something else takes its place. Maybe based on the SCP Foundation or the like. Yes I am committing to no Slenderman just to see how the CreepyPasta world evolves without him.
Where Bad Kids Go
Same as OTL, unless Lebanon is different ITTL.
Lebanon is different ITTL and I'm not sure when exactly the past events were intended to take place to comment but it likely does not exist or if it does is set in a different country. Imagine a North Korean version of this for example.
That is all I’ve got so far.
Honestly I was never into Creepy Pastas. I skimmed a few you listed and listened to some before and honestly still meh, though some i feel an irrational hatred for growing as I question why there were popular. I find most of them boring or not scary. However I don't hate Slenderman I just like the idea of him not existing both due to the extreme odds of a specific contest, specific participant, specific image and specific winner and the unlikelyhood of that. If you have more please DM them to me and next time just list the Same as OTL together in a paragraph or row.